StreetSmart/SF/Compare/Hayes Valley vs Russian Hill

Hayes Valley vs Russian Hill

Data-driven neighborhood comparison based on 2670 buildings

Hayes Valley
78
avg score (1215 buildings)
Russian Hill
81
avg score (1455 buildings)
⭐ Higher Rated

Side-by-Side Comparison

Metric
Hayes Valley
Russian Hill
⭐Average Score
78
81βœ“
πŸ“ŠMedian Score
80.684
83.293βœ“
🏠Rent Controlled (Pre-1979)
96%
98%βœ“
πŸ›οΈVictorian/Edwardian (Pre-1945)
92%βœ“
89%
⚠️Avg Open Violations
0.3
0.2βœ“
πŸͺ³Avg Pest Violations
0.4
0.3βœ“
πŸ”₯Avg Heat Violations
0.6
0.5βœ“
🏒Total Buildings (2+ units)
1215
1455βœ“

πŸ“‹ The Verdict

Russian Hill has a slight edge with an average building score of 81 compared to 78. However, both neighborhoods have excellent buildings, so focus on finding the right specific building rather than ruling out either area entirely.

Choose Hayes Valley if you want:
  • β€’ More Victorian/Edwardian character (92%)
Choose Russian Hill if you want:
  • β€’ More rent controlled options (98%)
  • β€’ Fewer open violations
  • β€’ More building options

Related

Last updated: 2026-01-09β€’Data sourcesβ€’How scoring worksβ€’Renter checklist