StreetSmart/Compare/Cobble Hill vs Carroll Gardens

Cobble Hill vs Carroll Gardens

Data-driven neighborhood comparison based on 220 buildings

Cobble Hill
79
avg score (46 buildings)
Carroll Gardens
84
avg score (174 buildings)
⭐ Higher Rated

Side-by-Side Comparison

Metric
Cobble Hill
Carroll Gardens
⭐Average Score
79
84✓
📊Median Score
86.9
92.2✓
🏠Likely Rent Stabilized
96%✓
84%
🏛ïļPre-War Buildings
93%✓
84%
⚠ïļAvg Open Violations
11.0✓
11.6
ðŸŠģAvg Pest Violations
2.1
1.3✓
ðŸ”ĨAvg Heat Violations
2.6
2.4✓
ðŸĒTotal Buildings (6+ units)
46
174✓

📋 The Verdict

Carroll Gardens has a slight edge with an average building score of 84 compared to 79. However, both neighborhoods have excellent buildings, so focus on finding the right specific building rather than ruling out either area entirely.

Choose Cobble Hill if you want:
  • â€Ē More rent stabilized options (96%)
  • â€Ē More pre-war character (93%)
  • â€Ē Fewer open violations
Choose Carroll Gardens if you want:
  • â€Ē More building options

Related

Last updated: 2025-12-22â€ĒData sourcesâ€ĒHow scoring worksâ€ĒRenter checklist